We are just mere days away from the 2019 NFL Draft, and honestly it can’t come soon enough. Not because we are massive fans and love the event, we are and we do, but it’s because if left in an NFL Draft limbo, well…
So with time to kill, we decided to whip up a list of the Top 10 rookie classes of the past ten years. Surprisingly, this was a tricky list to narrow down. If left to our own devices this would be a laundry list of Seattle Seahawk and New England Patriot draft classes, but we decided to mix things up a bit.
*UD denotes player signed as undrafted free agent
2009 Green Bay Packers
1.) B.J. Raji, DT, Boston College
1b.) Clay Matthews, OLB, USC
4.) T.J. Lang, OG, Eastern Michigan
5.) Quinn Johnson, FB, LSU
5b.) Jamon Meredith, OT, South Carolina
6.) Jarius Wynn, DE, Georgia
6b.) Brandon Underwood, DB, Cincinnati
7.) Brad Jones, OLB, Colorado
UD.) Evan Dietrich-Smith, C, Idaho St.
What a way to kick off a draft, huh? Three straight Pro Bowlers? That’s just impressive. Raji and Matthews were early building blocks for then-GM Ted Thompson. Thompson believed in drafting and developing rosters and this is a perfect example. Raji and Matthews were instant stars and helped the Packers to win Super Bowl XLV.
The development shines in regards to Lang and Jones. Lang, took over starting duties in 2011 and held down the spot for six straight years before cashing in with Detroit via free agency. Jones, started off as a special teams ace and worked his way in to the starting lineup for a few years.
Now, while none remain on the team following Matthews signing with Los Angeles this offseason, the impact these players had for the organization is inarguable. And perhaps most important of all, this draft class gave us one of the best dances ever in football…
2010 New York Giants
1.) Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, South Florida
2.) Linval Joseph, DT, East Carolina
4.) Phillip Dillard, LB, Nebraska
5.) Mitch Petrus, OG, Arkansas
6.) Adrian Tracy, LB, William & Mary
7.) Matt Dodge, P, East Carolina
UD.) Jake Ballard, TE, Ohio St.
UD.) Victor Cruz, WR, UMass
The top and bottom of this draft class explains everything. With the Michael Strahan era ending, following the Giants miracle Super Bowl run in 2007, and veterans Osi Umenyiora and Just Tuck not providing enough pass rush, the Giants went out and revamped their defensive line with their first two draft picks. Paul, was the speed demon off the edge that they were clearly missing, and Joseph was the mountain in the middle who clogged up the running lanes.
At the bottom, you have the signings of Ballard and Cruz, needed bodies to increase competition at the weak skill positions on offense. The result one year later? Ballard, is the starting tight end in Super Bowl XLVI, and Cruz is Second Team All-Pro. Oh, and once again, the Giants went on a miracle Super Bowl run!
2011 Seattle Seahawks
1.) James Carpenter, OG, Alabama
3.) John Moffitt, OG, Georgia
4.) K.J. Wright, LB, Mississippi St.
4b.) Kris Durham, WR, Georgia
5.) Richard Sherman, CB, Stanford
5b.) Mark LeGree, S, Appalachian St.
6.) Byron Maxwell, CB, Clemson
7.) Lazarius Levingston, DE, LSU
7.) Malcolm Smith, LB, USC
UD.) Doug Baldwin, WR, Stanford
Maybe the hardest part of coming up with this article was trying to figure out which Seattle Sehawks’ draft to highlight. Do we go with the one where they pick two All-Pro safeties? The draft where they land a franchise quarterback in the third round? Ultimately, I went with this one, because they landed a future Hall-of-Fame cornerback, a Super Bowl MVP, and stalwart wide receiver.
Now agreed, there are plenty of misses here. Moffitt, Durham, and Levingston flamed out quickly. But the achievements of the other players far outweigh their lack of impact for the organization.
Carpenter, helped pave the way for running back Marshawn Lynch, who was the focal point of the Seahawks offense at this point in time. Further adding to the offense was the undrafted free agent acquisition of Doug Baldwin. Baldwin, fought his way up the depth chart, starting over half the season in 2013 and has provided Russel Wilson with a reliable target ever since.
On the defensive side of the ball, this was the draft class that put the team over the top and gave us the Legion of Boom. Sherman, hit the ground running and picked off four passes as a rookie. Maxwell, like Baldwin, worked his way into the starting lineup and would eventually start in Super Bowl XLIX, opposite Sherman, before departing to sign with Philadelphia for $63 million.
Among the linebacking corps, Wright and Smith adapted quickly. Wright, took over a starting spot and hasn’t given it up nearly a decade on. As for Smith, he was a part-time starter, but one of those starts would come in the Super Bowl and he would go on become MVP after racking up nine tackles, recovering a fumble, and scoring a pick-six. Not too shabby.
2012 Indianapolis Colts
1.) Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford
2.) Coby Fleener, TE, Stanford
3.) Dwayne Allen, TE, Clemson
3.) T.Y. Hilton, WR, Florida International
5.) Josh Chapman, DT, Alabama
5b.) Vick Ballard, RB, Mississippi St.
6.) LaVon Brazil, WR, Ohio
6b.) Justin Anderson, OG, Georgia
7.) Tim Fugger, DE, Vanderbilt
7b.) Chandler Harnish, QB, NIU
Now, on first look this not a stellar draft class, as there was little to no impact from half of this draft class. Those that did contribute, however, did so in a big way, that being in transitioning the franchise to life after Peyton Manning.
Remember, back in the spring of 2012, the Indianans Colts released legendary quarterback Peyton Manning after he missed all of the 2011 season due to a neck injury. The team cratered that year and was awarded the top pick in the draft, which couldn’t have happened at a better time as the Colts had the option of choosing two generational quarterback talents in Stanford’s Andrew Luck and Baylor’s, Heisman winning, Robert Griffin III.
Ryan Grigson, the newly promoted first-year general manager, made the (rare) right choice in selecting Luck to be the new face of the franchise and landed quality weapons to surround him with in Fleener, Allen, Hilton, and Ballard.
While Fleener and Allen have left the organization, and Ballard’s promising career was cut short due to injury, Luck and Hilton have made a combined eight Pro Bowls.
2014 Oakland Raiders
1.) Khalil Mack, DE, Buffalo
2.) Derek Carr, QB, Fresno St.
3.) Gabe Jackson, OG, Mississippi St.
4.) Justin Ellis, DT, Louisiana Tech
4b.) Keith McGill, CB, Utah
7.) TJ Carrie, CB, Ohio
7b.) Shelby Harris, DE, Illinois St.
7c.) Jonathan Dowling, S, Western Kentucky
Apologies in advance to any Oakland Raiders fans out there. I know this hurts to look at, but this is a damn good draft class. Granted current head coach Jon Gruden is in the midst of destroying it, this is what a franchise altering draft looks like.
The Raiders landed a future hall-of-famer in Mack, a Pro Bowl quarterback in Carr, and a pair of stalwarts along the trenches in Jackson and Ellis. It’s actually hard to believe that Jackson hasn’t made a Pro Bowl yet, but that’s a topic for another time.
The real impressive feat, after acquiring all that superstar talent, was that Raiders then-GM Reggie McKenzie landed quality depth pieces late in McGill, Carrie, and Harris. While, McGill hung around for a few years, Carrie emerged as a valuable nickleback before emerging as a starter, and Harris has developed into a quality rotation lineman albeit for the divisional rival Broncos.
Again, apologies to Raiders fans. But look at the bright side, you have Antonio Brown, and what is more Raider football than this…
2015 New England Patriots
1.) Malcom Brown, DT, Texas
2.) Jordan Richards, S, Rutgers
3.) Geno Grissom, DE, Rutgers
4.) Trey Flowers, DE, Arkansas
4b.) Tre Jackson, OG, Florida St.
4c.) Shaq Mason, OG, Georgia Tech
5.) Joe Cardona, LS, Navy
6.) Matthew Wells, LB, Mississippi St.
6b.) A.J. Derby, TE, Arkansas
7.) Darryl Roberts, CB, Marshall
7b.) Xzavier Dickson, LB, Alabama
UD.) Brandon King, S, Auburn
Now, a lot of the talent has left from this draft, we know, but this is a great example of how Belichick built a second franchise. In 2010, they began to build the foundation of what would be this current Patriots dynasty (Devin McCourty, Rob Gronkowski) and they would win a Super Bowl with that group of players.
But it was the additions of Brown, Flowers, Mason, Cardona, and King that would build the foundation to win two more Super Bowls.
The Patriots effectively whiffed on their first three selections in Brown, Richards, and Grissom. Brown, was a quality rotational defender, but you always want more out of your first-round pick. Richards and Grissom were part-time special teamers.
It’s the fourth-round that shows how good drafting pays off. Flowers and Mason, have developed into premier players at their positions. While, neither has made the Pro Bowl (astonishingly), Flowers landed a $90 million contract with Detroit this offseason and Mason was graded as the fourth best of ALL lineman in 2018, according to Pro Football Focus.
Oh, and there was maybe the greatest draft choice of Belichick’s entire tenure, when he drafted Cardona out of Navy…the highest a long snapper has ever been drafted.
2016 Atlanta Falcons
1.) Keanu Neal, S, Florida
2.) Deion Jones, LB, LSU
3.) Austin Hooper, TE, Stanford
4.) De’Vondre Campbell, LB, Minnesota
6.) Wes Schweitzer, OG, San Jose St.
7.) Devin Fuller, WR, UCLA
This is a wildly impressive draft class. It’s easy to forget how good these players are, because most were hurt last season. Hitting on four of your six draft picks is just tremendous, especially when considering they take the New England Patriots down to the wire in the Super Bowl as rookies.
Neal and Jones were injured all of last season and that really sucked the heart out of the defensive. The pair have already made the Pro Bowl and set the tone of the defense, something head coach Gus Bradley relies on.
Hooper, broke out for a career year in 2018, posting 71 receptions for 660 yards and four touchdowns. More will be expected of him in 2019. Campbell, remained healthy for the campaign and had another productive year flying sideline to sideline.
2016 Dallas Cowboys
1.) Ezekiel Elliott, RB, Ohio St.
2.) Jaylon Smith, LB, Notre Dame
3.) Maliek Collins, DT, Nebraska
4.) Charles Tapper, DE, Oklahoma
4b.) Dak Prescott, QB, Mississippi St.
6.) Anthony Brown, CB, Purdue
6b.) Kavon Frazier, S, Central Michigan
6c.) Darius Jackson, RB, Eastern Michigan
6d.) Rico Gathers, TE, Baylor
Talk about franchise altering drafts. Landing the spine of your offense in one swing is impressive, landing Pro Bowl talent at those positions is even more impressive. Elliott and Prescott, have the ability to get the Cowboys back to the Super Bowl. That takes a lot of pressure off the front office, especially when the offensive line is already intact to boot.
One of the real bright spots here is Smith. Smith, was a Top 10 talent before suffering a devastating knee injury in his final collegiate game. The Cowboys gambled and Smith sat out the entire 2016 season to get healthy. In his two years back playing, he has proven to be the force he was originally considered.
Collins, emerged as a starter from the get-go. While he only appeared in thirteen games last year, he should be fully ready for the 2019 season. Brown, was another big hit for the Cowboys, who has taken the mantle of starter since his rookie season.
2017 New Orleans Saints
1.) Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio St.
1b.) Ryan Ramczyk, OT, Wisconsin
2.) Marcus Williams, S, Utah
3.) Alvin Kamara, RB, Tennessee
3b.) Alex Anzalone, LB, Florida
3c.) Trey Hendrickson, DE, Florida Atlantic
6.) Al-Quadin Muhammad, DE, Miami
UD.) Taysom Hill, QB, BYU
Remember two second ago when we mentioned a franchise altering draft? Here’s another one. The Saints went all in on this draft class and it payed off immediately. Lattimore and Kamara are already Pro Bowlers and it wouldn’t be surprising to see Ramczyk and Williams join them in those ranks soon.
Lattimore and Ramczyk, solved big questions for the franchise. At the time cornerback had been a mess for years, and along the offensive line, trusted veteran Zach Strief had recently retired. Adding the pair of first-rounders when they did couldn’t be a greater success.
The third round here is particularly impressive. Landing one of the most dynamic and dangerous players in the entire league in the third round is just unheard of. Kamara, is a versatile threat that has left teams kicking themselves for not selecting him earlier.
2018 Cleveland Browns
1.) Baker Mayfield, QB, Oklahoma
1b.) Denzel Ward, CB, Ohio St.
2.) Austin Corbett, OL, Nevada
2b.) Nick Chubb, RB, Georgia
3.) Chad Thomas, DE, Miami
4.) Antonio Callaway, WR, Florida
5.) Genard Avery, LB, Memphis
6.) Damion Ratley, WR, Texas A&M
6b.) Simeon Thomas, CB, Louisiana
You knew it was coming at some point, right? How could we not mention last year’s stellar Cleveland Browns draft class. We keep mentioning franchise altering draft classes, and this has the makeup to be another one.
The first rounders were overall surprising. Mayfield, isn’t you’re typical franchise quarterback, but he is one helluva leader. We all know what Mayfield is, and if anyone is going to turn around the misfortunes of the Dawg Pound it’s Mayfield. The diminutive Ward was also a surprising selection. There were so many questions about his size leading into the draft and Ward answered them by putting in a Pro Bowl season.
The additions in the trenches in (Corbett and Thomas) still need developing, but the future is still bright for those two. The skill positions in Chubb and Callaway, were big hits. Chubb, proved that he shouldn’t have fallen into the second round and Callaway will be moved to the slot in 2019, allowing even greater utilization of his speed.
The really interesting pick, though? Avery. The former-Memphis Tiger, appeared in all 16 games and started five of them. He finished the season with 40 tackles and 4.5 sacks. Not to mention he broke up four passes and forced a fumble. The team was so convinced by his play that they cut veteran Jamie Collins.
Overall, it will be incredibly exciting to see where this draft class goes.